Tyson Crotty

About Tyson Crotty

Tyson is a Senior Financial Adviser and Director of Finspective. Read More about Tyson

November 19, 2026

You’re making all the right financial decisions and still getting it wrong.

I make bad financial decisions too. I’ve probably made hundreds of them. There, the Financial Adviser confesses. 

I’ve bought things I didn’t need. Held onto things too long. Sold things too early. Paid more tax than was absolutely necessary. I’ve procrastinated on things I knew I should do and spent countless hours researching things that, in hindsight, barely mattered. And I’m pretty comfortable with that.

Because I don’t think financial success comes from making perfect financial decisions. In fact, something concerns me more.

People who make almost nothing but good financial decisions and still don’t end up with the life they actually wanted.

Is there such a thing as too many good financial decisions?

Imagine a couple in their early 40s. They earn good money, have a sizeable mortgage, healthy super balances and a couple of kids who somehow make the house feel smaller every year. They’d love a better family home.

But financially, there are plenty of reasons not to do it.

Keep smashing down the mortgage and they’ll save plenty of interest. Contribute more to super and they’ll probably pay less tax while accumulating more for retirement. Excellent financial decisions. So they stay put.

Fast-forward 20 years. The kids have left home. The mortgage is gone. Their super has grown to substantially more than they’re ever likely to spend. They’ve done extremely well financially.

Except now they don’t need the bigger house.

The years when another bedroom, a bigger backyard and a house full of kids and their friends would have added something meaningful to their lives have passed. You can’t go back and buy those years. That’s the problem with assessing financial decisions in isolation.

Was paying down their mortgage a good decision? Absolutely.

Was contributing more to super tax-effective? Probably.

But those weren’t really the questions that mattered. The better question was –What are we trying to use our money to achieve, and when will that money be most valuable to us? Because a lifetime of financially sensible decisions doesn’t necessarily add up to a good life.

Life. Technical. Product. In that order.

When faced with an important financial decision, I like to think about it in three stages.

First is Life.

What are we actually trying to achieve? A better home while the kids are living with us? More time away from work? Helping the kids? Travelling? Retiring earlier?

Then comes Technical.

Can we afford it? What does it do to our debt, tax and retirement? What happens if investment returns disappoint? What are we giving up by making this choice?

Only then should we get to Product.

Which super fund? Which investment? Which loan? Which insurance policy? That order matters.  Because starting with the technical can produce a perfectly rational answer to the wrong question.

Should I contribute another $20,000 to super to save tax? Maybe.

But useful information is not the same as personalised Financial Advice. AI can help explain what something means, but it does not always understand what matters most in your situation. That difference becomes especially important when the decision you’re making is connected to a major life change.

But what else could that $20,000 do?

And there’s little benefit finding the perfect investment product for money that perhaps shouldn’t have been invested in the first place. Life tells you what you’re trying to achieve. Technical tells you what’s possible and what you’re trading off. Product is how you implement it.

Refinancing to a new loan type
Trust and Estate Planning

Having less money can sometimes be the better outcome

Suppose buying the family home you really want means you’re projected to have $500,000 less at retirement. That sounds bad. What if the numbers also show that, even after buying the home, you’re still likely to comfortably fund the retirement you want?

Now we have an interesting decision. Is the extra $500,000 more valuable to you as empty nesters in your seventies? Or could some of it create significantly more value for your family in your forties?

A spreadsheet can’t answer that question. 

But it can tell you whether you can afford to ask it. That’s an important distinction.

Sometimes good financial planning shouldn’t be about finding the option that leaves you with the most money. It should help you understand the choices actually available, what they’re likely to cost and what you’re giving up by choosing one over another.

Then you make the life decision.

Don’t ignore the boring decisions either

Of course, this doesn’t mean you should forget about the little things and spend everything today. Some seemingly insignificant decisions become enormous simply because you repeat them.

Direct $100 a week from a pay rise towards your mortgage, investments or super and it doesn’t change much this month. Keep doing it for 20 years and you’ve directed $104,000 somewhere productive before considering investment earnings or interest savings.

Time can turn small, boring decisions into enormous ones.

So can leaving your super invested appropriately for decades, consistently paying a little extra off your mortgage or investing part of future salary increases instead of allowing every pay rise to become lifestyle.

The important decisions aren’t always the ones with big dollar signs attached today.

What are you actually building wealth for?

Over your lifetime, you’ll make thousands of financial decisions. You’ll get plenty wrong. I certainly will.

Some decisions matter because they’re huge. Some matter because they’re small decisions repeated for decades. And some matter because there’s a period in your life when the money can do something for you that it simply can’t do later.

That’s why I’m wary of defining financial success as simply accumulating more.

Having plenty of money at 70 is a wonderful outcome. But not if you unnecessarily sacrificed things that mattered enormously at 40 to accumulate money you’re unlikely to need. So perhaps there’s a more important question than whether you’re making good financial decisions.

Are you building wealth for something, or have you simply become very good at building wealth?

You don’t need to get every financial decision right.

Understand what you’re trying to achieve. Understand your alternatives and what you’re giving up. Test the numbers when the consequences warrant it. Then make the decision and get on with living your life.

Just make sure the ones that matter weren’t decided by accident.

If you’re after a Financial Adviser that will guide your investment years and wealth creation strategies, Finspective can help. Check out our Investing & Wealth Creation page for more information.

Investing & Wealth Creation

Any advice on this site is general nature only and has not been tailored to your personal objectives, financial situation and needs. Please seek personal advice prior to acting on this information. Any advice on this website has been prepared without taking account of your objectives, financial situation or needs. Because of that, before acting on the advice, you should consider its appropriateness to you, having regard to your objectives, financial situation or needs.